Casselberry: Casselberry City Commission - Invocation Discussion - 9 November 2015
Summary. The Casselberry City Commission held a discussion on November 19, 2015, regarding meeting policies, specifically focusing on the inclusion of invocations in their regular meetings. City Attorney Katie Reichman presented legal analysis based on the Supreme Court decision in Town of Greece v. Galloway, explaining that while legislative prayer is constitutionally permissible, there are legal risks including potential lawsuits and attorney fees. She recommended either adopting a moment of silence with nonsectarian remarks or developing a comprehensive prayer policy similar to what the Town of Greece used. The commission was divided on the approach. Vice Mayor Solomon strongly advocated for a moment of silence as the simplest and safest option, noting that many other cities including Altamonte, Winter Park, Lake Mary, and Orlando had already adopted this approach. The Mayor and some commissioners preferred to attempt developing a prayer policy that would allow various religious organizations from the community to provide invocations, while being inclusive of all religions but potentially excluding non-religious groups. After extensive discussion about the legal complexities and practical challenges, the commission reached a consensus to direct staff to develop a prayer policy following the Supreme Court guidelines, with the understanding that they could later switch to a moment of silence if the policy proved unworkable.
Agenda Items
G. Discussion relating to city commission meeting and agenda policies
Review of current meeting policies with focus on invocation practices following Supreme Court guidance
- Legal analysis of Town of Greece v. Galloway Supreme Court decision
- Risk of litigation and potential attorney fees in federal court
- Options including moment of silence vs. prayer policy
- Examples of other cities that have adopted moment of silence
- Guidelines for inclusive prayer policies
- Concerns about protecting city from legal challenges while maintaining tradition
Action Items
Develop a prayer policy following Supreme Court guidelines from Town of Greece decision
Assigned to City Attorney and Staff
Frequently Asked Questions
What was decided at this meeting?
The Casselberry City Commission held a discussion on November 19, 2015, regarding meeting policies, specifically focusing on the inclusion of invocations in their regular meetings. City Attorney Katie Reichman presented legal analysis based on the Supreme Court decision in Town of Greece v. Galloway, explaining that while legislative prayer is constitutionally permissible, there are legal risks including potential lawsuits and attorney fees. She recommended either adopting a moment of silence with nonsectarian remarks or developing a comprehensive prayer policy similar to what the Town of Greece used. The commission was divided on the approach. Vice Mayor Solomon strongly advocated for a moment of silence as the simplest and safest option, noting that many other cities including Altamonte, Winter Park, Lake Mary, and Orlando had already adopted this approach. The Mayor and some commissioners preferred to attempt developing a prayer policy that would allow various religious organizations from the community to provide invocations, while being inclusive of all religions but potentially excluding non-religious groups. After extensive discussion about the legal complexities and practical challenges, the commission reached a consensus to direct staff to develop a prayer policy following the Supreme Court guidelines, with the understanding that they could later switch to a moment of silence if the policy proved unworkable.
What was on the agenda?
This meeting covered 1 agenda item: Discussion relating to city commission meeting and agenda policies.
What action items came out of this meeting?
1 action item were identified. See the Action Items section above for details and who they were assigned to.
Who attended this meeting?
7 members were recorded as present: Mayor, City Manager, City Attorney Katie Reichman, Vice Mayor Solomon, Commissioner Omidy, Commissioner Meadows, Commissioner (Speaker 5).
Where can I watch the full recording?
The full video recording is available on YouTube or embedded at the top of this page.
What county is Casselberry in?
Casselberry is located in Seminole County, Florida. Browse other Seminole County meeting summaries to see what local governments across the county are working on.
Want summaries like this for your city?
CivicMinutes generates plain-language summaries of council and commission meetings so residents stay informed without watching hours of video.